24" x 36" Rectangular Decorative Mirror with Rounded Corners

24" x 36" Rectangular Decorative Mirror with Rounded Corners by Threshold x Studio McGee — mirrors, Overall: 24" W x 1.27" D x 36" H. Compare it with similar pieces across brands, and see the rooms it appears in.

24" x 36" Rectangular Decorative Mirror with Rounded Corners by Threshold x Studio McGee
  • Brand: Threshold x Studio McGee
  • Category: Mirrors
  • Price: $105
  • Dimensions: Overall: 24" W x 1.27" D x 36" H
  • Rooms: Living room
See it at Threshold x Studio McGee

Room×Lab Review · Review updated August 28, 2026

Owners praise the large, designer look for the money, but Antique Black often reads gray and some mirrors arrive damaged or distorted

Room×Lab read every written Target review of this 24-by-36-inch mirror: 267 distinct written reviews across all five star ratings, posted from April 2020 through August 2026. They cover both finishes, Antique Black and Brass, plus reviews posted to the main product listing. What owners say applies to both finishes unless it concerns color or finish. The reviews below run from five stars to one. They show the most common praise and the main complaints: finish color, a warped reflection, bathroom rust and a mirror that arrived shattered.

Room×Lab rating: 7.1 out of 10 (limited confidence). Owners of both finishes praise the large, polished silhouette and the value for the money. The caveats: Antique Black often looks gray, Brass can look flat, and owners report mirrors arriving damaged or with a warped reflection, rust in bathrooms, fiddly keyhole hanging and replacements that were hard to get.

  • High-end scale at an accessible price: 70 favorable mentions; 68 concerns — Owners often saw it as an affordable way to get a large, designer-looking mirror. Those who felt it was poor value cite defects, bathroom rust, a warped reflection or a finish that looked cheap.
  • Finish expectations can make or break the purchase: 29 favorable mentions; 80 concerns — Antique Black often reads gray or brown-charcoal rather than true black; Brass strikes some owners as muted and sophisticated, others as flat or spray-painted. Owners also report rough paint, visible seams, dents and scratches.
  • Substantial feel, but meaningful durability caveats: 11 favorable mentions; 21 concerns — Some owners praise a sturdy, substantial build. Recurring concerns include rust in bathrooms (one owner saw it after about six months, with heavy deterioration within a year), damaged reflective surfaces, bent frames and backing damaged during hanging.

Before buying

Antique Black can read gray and Brass can look flat. Check for damage or a warped reflection on arrival, plan anchors for 16.7 pounds and keyhole hanging, and note that owners report rust in steamy bathrooms.

Browse every mirrors review

More mirrors

Browse every mirrors in the catalog