Gabriola Pillow Set

Room×Lab Review · Review updated August 28, 2026

Dover Gray owners praise the soft bouclé and easy color matching; across Gabriola colors, flat inserts are the recurring complaint

Room×Lab read all 194 distinct written reviews among Article's 295 ratings. Article shows reviews of other Gabriola colors, fabrics and sizes on this page, so these reviews describe the Gabriola pillow range as a whole. Two owners quoted below reviewed the Dover Gray set. The rest describe other or unnamed Gabriola colors and sizes. Three reviews were incentivized; none of the reviews quoted below were. We picked the two Dover Gray reviews and four complaints about flat, underfilled or collapsing inserts, the recurring complaint across Gabriola colors; one of them also found the pillows rough.

Room×Lab rating: 7.2 out of 10 (limited confidence). Dover Gray owners praise the soft bouclé, comfortable back support and easy color matching, and reviews across Gabriola colors describe well-made covers, seams and zippers. The main caveat across those colors is repeated reports of inserts that stay flat, collapse during use or need replacing.

• Sturdy covers, inconsistent inserts: 90 favorable mentions; 79 concerns — Praise centers on the bouclé fabric, seams and zippers. Concerns center on the inserts: some stayed flat, felt flimsy and underfilled, or collapsed during use and had to be replaced. Counts cover written reviews across Gabriola colors.
• Comfort depends on texture and loft: 28 favorable mentions; 24 concerns — Many owners described the pillows as soft, supportive or pleasantly structured; others found them rough or stiff, noticed crinkling, or felt too little padding. Counts cover written reviews across Gabriola colors.
• Color and finish are a leading strength: 51 favorable mentions; 6 concerns — Bouclé texture and coordinating colors drew frequent approval. The 6 concerns included an isolated color mismatch between pillow sizes and dislike of the corner label. Counts cover written reviews across Gabriola colors.

Before buying

Choose this set for the soft gray bouclé covers Dover Gray owners praise. Expect to fluff the feather-and-microfiber inserts, and be ready to replace them if they arrive flat or lose fullness, a recurring complaint across Gabriola colors.

More decorative pillows reviews

• European Linen Euro ShamQuince · 709 owner comments checked
• Decorative Knife Edge Pillows 18 x 18 (Set of 2)Joybird · 345 owner comments checked
• Relaxed Washed Organic Cotton Velvet 20"x20" Ivory Throw Pillow CoverCrate & Barrel · 170 owner comments checked
• Sashiko Organic Cotton Velvet 20"x20" Blue Throw Pillow CoverCrate & Barrel · 124 owner comments checked
• Stitch Pillow - AquaArticle · 96 owner comments checked
• Lanna Sheepskin Seat Pad Set - IvoryArticle · 86 owner comments checked

Browse every decorative pillows review

More decorative pillows

Browse every decorative pillows in the catalog

• Furniture
• Lighting
• Rugs
• Décor
• Bedding & Textiles
• Kitchen & Table